Mahoning County, Ohio
Rentals in
New Middletown.
Find houses, apartments and duplexes for rent in New Middletown, Ohio, with ZIP codes, a free local fact sheet and nearby communities.
Area guide
Living in New Middletown
Find houses, apartments and duplexes for rent in New Middletown, Ohio, with ZIP codes, a free local fact sheet and nearby communities.
Looking for a place to rent in New Middletown, Ohio? RentYTown is an independent directory of local houses, apartments and duplexes in the Village of New Middletown and across Mahoning County. New Middletown is served by ZIP code 44442.
About New Middletown
New Middletown is a village in Springfield Township in southeastern Mahoning County. It blends small town living with easy access to Boardman, Poland and western Pennsylvania.
Finding a Rental in New Middletown
Use the RentYTown search to filter local listings by property type, school district, price range and pet policy, then check the area map for school zones and nearby amenities. Before you sign a lease, download the free New Middletown fact sheet for ZIP codes, schools and public safety information.
Nearby Communities
Common questions
Renting in New Middletown
Quick answers for renters and property owners.
What ZIP codes serve New Middletown, Ohio?
New Middletown is served by ZIP code 44442.
What county is New Middletown in?
New Middletown is in Mahoning County, Ohio, part of the Mahoning Valley in northeast Ohio.
How do I find a rental in New Middletown, Ohio?
Search RentYTown listings by property type, school district, price range and pet policy, check the area map for school zones, and download the free New Middletown fact sheet for schools and public safety information.
Can I list my New Middletown rental on RentYTown?
Yes. Landlords and property managers can list houses, apartments and duplexes in New Middletown using the List a property form on RentYTown.
For owners
Have a rental in New Middletown?
List your house, apartment, or duplex on RentYTown and reach renters searching for homes in New Middletown and across the Mahoning Valley.